Reflecting on 12 Months of Opening Up the Social Web

A few ago, I was in DC for the Graphing Social Patterns East conference, where I was on a panel moderated by Brian Oberkirch. Before the panel, he shot a video interview with me that he just put up today.

It’s a pretty decent “deep dive” on the topic of progress toward opening up the Social Web, and I highlight the last remaining issue, which I assert will get decided on not by fiat, but by marketplace competition. The issue? Is a friends list like and address book, with an undisputed single owner, or is it joint property of all the people on it? If that’s of interest to you, I think you’ll enjoy this video.

The Inspiration for Gnip

When you heard that Gnip launched yesterday, did you immediately get that their name is “Ping” spelled backwards? I did, but many of my colleagues didn’t. Why? Because they were too young to remember that cheesy ’70’s game called “Gnip Gnop” (Ping pong, spelled backward.)

So, I thought I’d share the TV commercial for that long lost game.

Oh, and if you want to know more about what Gnip is and why it’s important, check out the video session we shot over at TechCrunch HQ yesterday.

Gnip Flips the Aggregation Model from Pull to Push

Have you ever found yourself refreshing your browser while watching the river of content in your aggregator of choice, wondering why your latest photos, blogpost, or tweets haven’t shown up? “Are they there now?” Pause. “How about now?” Sigh.

A company launching today, Gnip, seeks to cure the “aggregation latency” problem, by flipping the model from one in which the aggregators periodically pull data from all the different social media sites to one in which updates are pushed to them from a single service (Gnip).

Is there really a need for such a service?

When Plaxo launched Pulse last August, kicking off a wave of social media aggregation that would spawn FriendFeed, Iminta, Social Thing, among others, the various social media sites, like Twitter, Flickr, and Digg, were not not expecting them. They had not built out infrastructure to handle a rising tide of requests for updates. Each aggregator had to figure out how frequently it could send out its crawlers without running into throttles at the various social media sites. And each social media site had to figure out how best to handle this new load coming from other services, rather than directly from their users.

All of the parties are now wrestling with scaling this model. And seeing that, the guys at Gnip saw an opportunity. It’s really interesting to watch the Social Web ecosystem beginning to emerge. As my readers know, I’m a big believer that aggregation is a critical core of that ecosystem, because in an era when most of the Web is social, aggregators provide the only way for mainstream users to keep up with what their family and friends are creating and sharing online.

Joseph Smarr of Plaxo has a nice post, explaining it in more detail. Also ReadWriteWeb’s Marshal Kirkpatrick has thoughtful analysis.

[Reminder/disclosure: I work at Plaxo, one of the companies discussed in this post.]

Tagged , , ,

MySpace Shipping “Data Availability” Today

Myspace_Logo

There are reports this morning from TechCrunch’s Michael Arrington, CNET’s Caroline McCarthy, and Mashable’s Adam Ostrow that MySpace will launch “Data Availability” today, delivering the code to back up their hastily launched press release of a few weeks ago.

It’s great to see the rush now to deliver various initiatives to tear down the walls that keep users from their data. Google has Friend Connect live on several sites in partnership with Plaxo. MySpace is making Data Availability available to all developers this afternoon. And Facebook is generally expected to deliver on the promise of Facebook Connect later this summer (perhaps at F8).

That said, I don’t believe the initial implementation of MySpace Data Availability will deliver on what those of us pushing to open up the Social Web are hoping for. The restrictions on participating third parties are so severe as to be impractical; specifically, caching of the data is prohibited. Rather than the walled garden castle lowering the drawbridge, this is more like opening the curtains.

What users should demand is convenient, secure, and unrestricted access to their data. That means the ability to have full interoperability between any of the tools and services they use, including operations like import, sync, and delete.

Service operators, if you love your users’ data, set it free. If they love you, they will not leave. Instead, they will appreciate the convenience of interoperability that you are enabling.

UPDATE: I recommend the analysis by David Chartier over at Ars Technica.

Tagged , , ,

On “Federating Social Networks” Panel at Voice Peering Forum

On the Federating Social Networks Panel

A good discussion today at an unusual forum. The panel topic was “Federating Social Networks,” but the conference was the “Voice Peering Forum,” which was heavily focused on the telecommunications sector. Lots of networking folks there, so my (nerdy) joke for our panel was “Welcome to layer 8.”

Here was the lineup:

Chairperson:
Charlene Li
Vice President & Principal Analyst
Forrester Research

Panelists:
David L. Jones
Vice President of Global Marketing
Friendster

Patrick Chanezon
OpenSocial Developer Advocate
Google

Anil Dharni
Director of Products
hi5 Networks

John McCrea
Vice President, Marketing
Plaxo

Charlene asked the panelists to go on record predicting when the open version of the Social Web would emerge. I took the bold position (consistent with my post in December) that it would happen before the end of 2008!

Here’s the Pilot Episode of “The Social Web TV!”: (Talk to Our Lawyers…Bitch)

Trevor and Redgee Ready to Shoot the Pilot

As my frequent readers know, I am *passionate* about opening up the Social Web. I believe it is vitally important for the billion or so users of the Web today (and the billions more to come) that we *not* end up with the “walled garden” model, which denies people control of and access to their personal data and content.

We’ve made great progress in the past year, but how to do we take it to the next level? How do we step up our game?

For the answer to that question, I drew inspiration from the man shaking up the wine industry by embracing social media to democratize wine tasting, Gary Vaynerchuck. His Wine Library TV show rocks, and shows how to seize the tools available to us today to get the word out.

And so, on Thursday, I went into a conference room at Plaxo headquarters, along with David Recordon and Joseph Smarr, two digital camcorders, two microphones, a stellar production crew of Redgee Capili and Trevor Gattis. (With graphics/design support from Michael Rowley.)

The result?

A pilot episode called “Talk to or lawyers…bitch!

Let me know what you think.

“Whose Social Graph?” Panel at Supernova

"Whose Social Graph?" panel at Supernova

Rockin’ panel at Supernova.

A screenshot from a blogpost by David Recordon has set off a verbal firestorm.

Getting down and dirty now on why Facebook disabled Google’s Friend Connect. Dave Morin, who is a very capable spokesperson, is getting peppered with lots of questions. Sepcifically, the audience wants an answer to Google’s Kevin Marks’ question, “What can we do to get this feature re-enabled? How did we violate the TOS?” Dave has made clear that “representatives” from the two companies are talking, seeking a resolution. (Interpretation: lawyers.) Dave has had to defer on one more pointed question with, “Unfortunately, I have to defer on legal questions.”

Best panel of Supernova, so far. Great moderation by Tantek, who engaged the panelists and the audience. And Kevin, Joseph, and Dave represented their companies and their positions really well. Despite some controversy, it is clear that there is genuine intent to open up and enable interoperability — under the control of the user.

UPDATE: A thorough writeup by CNET’s Dan Farber is now up.

Tagged , , , , , ,

Day One at Supernova

 Opening Session

Up in SF with Joseph Smarr at the first day of Supernova. Great gathering. Vibrant hallway conversations. 

Not surprisingly, a very thoughtful presentation by Clay Shirky. Here’s a nice writeup by Dan Farber of CNET.

Best of show (so far) was the talk a few minutes ago by Google’s Joe Kraus. Great to hear his spin on a topic that I write about all the time — the transition from social networks to the Social Web. Among other things, he showed off Google Friend Connect, including showing the controversial ui that shows import from Facebook as feature currently “Disabled by Facebook”!

Joe Kraus showing Google Friend Connect

Michael Arrington at TechCrunch has a writeup that includes live video. I highly recommend it. Joe is a great public speaker and is a great spokeperson for opening up the Social Web.

 

Tagged , ,

A Portable Social Graph Spotted in the Wild: Plaxo Now Live in Google Friend Connect

In another sprint, Joseph Smarr and the team at Plaxo, working closely with their counterparts at Google, now have Plaxo/Friend Connect integration live. Joseph has a nice writeup on the Plaxo blog. [Reminder/disclaimer: I work at Plaxo.] [Screenshot below.]  

As regular readers know, I am a strong proponent of letting users access their local piece of the social graph at services all over the web. Clearly, Plaxo sees a market opportunity to become a major “social graph provider,” and this integration with Google Friend Connect is a good sign of progress in that effort. It is especially cool to see the “virtuous cycle” features of the integration; feeds of content flow back into Pulse from the Friend Connect site, enabling social discovery. In many ways, this looks like the beginning of the “Social Web.”

I’m currentyl in Washington, D.C. for the Graphing Social Patterns East conference, and will be speaking on a panel this afternoon on the Privacy and Data Portability. Facebook’s Dave Morin will be on it, so today’s news on Google Friend Connect should make for some interesting discussion.

Reactions coming in now. Nice post by David Recordon.

Tagged , , , ,

Yahoo! Opens Address Books; Plaxo and LinkedIn Already Live

In another part of its bold “Open Strategy”, Yahoo today announced public availability of its Address Book API. Plaxo, always first to embrace a new open technology, is already live with support, along with another major contact-aware service provider, LinkedIn.

This is an important step in the opening up of the Social Web. A few months ago, the only way to help a user import their contacts into a social web app was to ask them for their webmail username and password. Clearly, that’s a bad idea, but in the absence of address book APIs, it at least worked. Now, the Big Three all have contacts APIs: Microsoft, Google, and Yahoo! each have come out with APIs that give users secure access to their address books.

I sat down with Joseph Smarr of Plaxo to get the inside scoop. My interview is here:

And here’s coverage from TechCrunch’s Mark Hendrickson and from CNET’s Stephen Shankland.

[Disclaimer/reminder: I work for Plaxo, a company covered in this post.]